Character Name : Wayne Montgomery

Original Name : Paul McCloskey

Gender : Male

Character Name : Andrea Montgomery

Original Name : Barbara Lessin

Gender : Male

Character Name : John Craven

Original Name : Mark Cray

Gender : Male

Character Name : Kyle Stratten

Original Name : Michael Manfredo Jr.

Gender : Male

Character Name : Charles Craven

Original Name : Mark Marcarian

Gender : Male

Character Name : Luke Crossen

Original Name : Jeremy Bishop

Gender : Male

Character Name : Henry Crossen

Original Name : Nate Edwards

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Michael Hanlon

Original Name : Bill Ushler

Gender : Male

Character Name : Marti Dobson

Original Name : Lisa Panzer

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Joe Moretti

Original Name : Roberto Lombardi

Gender : Male

Character Name : Ray Olsen

Original Name : Jerry Ross

Gender : Male

Character Name : Grey Mortimer

Original Name : David M. Sitbon

Gender : Male

Character Name : Christopher Hagans

Original Name : Shawn Shillingford

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Paul Brewer

Original Name : Todd Kaylor

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective John Haynes

Original Name : Michael J. Panichelli Jr.

Gender : Male

Character Name : Todd Montgomery

Original Name : Bruce DeSantis

Gender : Male

Character Name : Monica Montgomery

Original Name : Emily Spiegel

Gender : Male

Character Name : Crime Scene Investigator

Original Name : Cara Duncan

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective David Shaw

Original Name : James Schaeffer

Gender : Male

Character Name : Reporter

Original Name : Jenn Phillips

Gender : Male

Character Name : Newscaster (voice)

Original Name : Fearon Derry

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Chris Dolendo

Original Name : Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Bill Price

Original Name : Tony J. Spadaccini

Gender : Male

Character Name : Seth Hayden

Original Name : Devin Kates

Gender : Male

Character Name : Jared

Original Name : Joey Garrison

Gender : Male

Character Name : Julie Quinn

Original Name : Brinke Stevens

Gender : Female

Character Name : Narrator (voice)

Original Name : Ruth Weisberg

Gender : Male

Character Name : Todd Montgomery - Age 2

Original Name : Daniel Eyre

Gender : Male

Character Name : Monica Montgomery- Baby

Original Name : Emily Eyre

Gender : Male

Character Name : Rebecca Collins

Original Name : Florence Coia

Gender : Male

Character Name : Charles Craven Jr.

Original Name : Damien Colletti

Gender : Male

Character Name : Joseph Barker

Original Name : Michael Agnew

Gender : Male

Character Name : Daniel Azzurri

Original Name : Brandon Macker

Gender : Male

Character Name : Alan Montgomery

Original Name : John Coia

Gender : Male

Character Name : Allison Stratten

Original Name : Sabrina Manfredo

Gender : Male

Character Name : Austin

Original Name : Taylor Sampere

Gender : Male

Character Name : Holly Craven

Original Name : Kati Jordan

Gender : Male

Character Name : Pete (Reaction Video #1)

Original Name : Kyle Field

Gender : Male

Character Name : Melissa (Reaction Video #2)

Original Name : Kelly Tull

Gender : Male

Character Name : Sarah (Reaction Video #2)

Original Name : Nikki Krumm

Gender : Male

Character Name : Brian (Reaction Video #3)

Original Name : Robbie Sanders

Gender : Male

Character Name : Chip (Reaction Video #4)

Original Name : Jack A. Walker

Gender : Male

Character Name : Gary (Reaction Video #5)

Original Name : Al Holmes

Gender : Male

Character Name : Marti’s Assistant

Original Name : June Munson

Gender : Male

Character Name : Detective Tony Capello

Original Name : Michael Manfredo

Gender : Male

Character Name : Marie Craven

Original Name : Jennifer Griffith-Munson

Gender : Male

Character Name : Chester Donnell

Original Name : Kevin Ashley

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Edward Kime

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Lucas Brown

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Dave Wrighteous

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Elizabeth Clark

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Allan Kleban

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Andrew Schwartz

Gender : Male

Character Name : Bookstore Customer

Original Name : Michael Oreszczyn

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Rin Cyano

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Amber Manfredo

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : William Ruh

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Matt Veltri

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Kelly Alexander

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Bailey Heintzelman

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Mikaela Knapp

Gender : Female

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Jay Cusack

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Bill Jackson

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Dave Wascavage

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Stacey Lowery

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Melissa Torrence

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Beth Sikma

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Erick Kneisler

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Fran Slaczka

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Sue Morrow

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Karen Kennedy

Gender : Male

Character Name : Victim

Original Name : Mary Brown

Gender : Male

Character Name : Debbie

Original Name : Glynis Sampere

Gender : Male

Character Name : D.B.I. Investigator

Original Name : Lauren Gaskell

Gender : Male

Character Name : Mike

Original Name : Derek Rushlow

Gender : Male

Character Name : Fortunato

Original Name : Brendan Bertolini

Gender : Male

Character Name : Lewis

Original Name : Eric Moyer

Gender : Male