Character Name : Ben Dwellman

Original Name : Jason Ritter

Gender : Male

Character Name : Alan Manilow

Original Name : Jake Sandvig

Gender : Male

Character Name : Kelsey Patterson

Original Name : Chandler Canterbury

Gender : Male

Character Name : Melanie 'Mel' Manilow

Original Name : Rebecca Hall

Gender : Female

Character Name : Marty

Original Name : Todd Louiso

Gender : Male

Character Name : Wyatt

Original Name : Gabriel Macht

Gender : Male

Character Name : Older Jewish Lady

Original Name : Sally Kirkland

Gender : Female

Character Name : The Mark

Original Name : Elmarie Wendel

Gender : Female

Character Name : Lynette

Original Name : Carrie Preston

Gender : Female

Character Name : Kelsey Patterson (Age 18)

Original Name : Johnny Simmons

Gender : Male

Character Name : Amanda (uncredited)

Original Name : Amanda Seyfried

Gender : Female