Character Name : Gerry Fenn

Original Name : Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Gender : Male

Character Name : Alice

Original Name : Cricket Brown

Gender : Female

Character Name : Father Hagan

Original Name : William Sadler

Gender : Male

Character Name : Natalie Gates

Original Name : Katie Aselton

Gender : Female

Character Name : Bishop Gyles

Original Name : Cary Elwes

Gender : Male

Character Name : Delgarde

Original Name : Diogo Morgado

Gender : Male

Character Name : Geary

Original Name : Bates Wilder

Gender : Male

Character Name : Mary of Elnor

Original Name : Marina Mazepa

Gender : Female

Character Name : Monica Slade

Original Name : Christine Adams

Gender : Female

Character Name : Dan Walsh

Original Name : Dustin Tucker

Gender : Male

Character Name : Sophia Walsh

Original Name : Gisela Chípe

Gender : Female

Character Name : Toby Walsh

Original Name : Danny Corbo

Gender : Male

Character Name : Toby Walsh

Original Name : Sonny Corbo

Gender : Male

Character Name : Max

Original Name : Michael Strauss

Gender : Male

Character Name : Faithful Teen Girl

Original Name : Madison LaPlante

Gender : Female

Character Name : Waitress

Original Name : Doria Bramante

Gender : Female

Character Name : Atheist Man

Original Name : Stephen O'Neil Martin

Gender : Male

Character Name : Correspondent

Original Name : Tim Estiloz

Gender : Male

Character Name : Correspondent

Original Name : Ted Wayman

Gender : Male

Character Name : Internet Woman

Original Name : Andrea Athanassiou

Gender : Male

Character Name : Internet Woman

Original Name : Hannah Jane Doyon

Gender : Female

Character Name : Librarian

Original Name : Celeste Oliva

Gender : Female

Character Name : Shopkeeper

Original Name : Chris Byers

Gender : Male

Character Name : Faithful #1

Original Name : Mere Davis

Gender : Female

Character Name : Faithful #2

Original Name : Dave Heard

Gender : Male

Character Name : Faithful #3

Original Name : Kiara Pichardo

Gender : Female

Character Name : Faithful #4

Original Name : Kevin Fennessy

Gender : Male

Character Name : Nervous Man Leaving Town

Original Name : Charlie Thurston

Gender : Male

Character Name : Blacksmith

Original Name : Mike Wendt

Gender : Male

Character Name : Journalist

Original Name : Lisa Gresci

Gender : Male

Character Name : Father Prescott

Original Name : Bill Thorpe

Gender : Male

Character Name : Mary Elnor (voice)

Original Name : Lorna Larkin

Gender : Female

Character Name : Grace Father (uncredited)

Original Name : Cassidy Neal

Gender : Male

Character Name : City Official (uncredited)

Original Name : Rob Lévesque

Gender : Male

Character Name : Talk Show Host (uncredited)

Original Name : J.J. Wright

Gender : Male

Character Name : Camera Crew (uncredited)

Original Name : Adrian M. Mompoint

Gender : Male

Character Name : Church Goer (uncredited)

Original Name : Jonathan Neves

Gender : Male

Character Name : Church Member (uncredited)

Original Name : Nicholas Trotto

Gender : Male